The image is a two-panel comic. The top panel shows a hand hovering over two red buttons. The buttons are labeled "Admit that I cheated with a local goat herder" and "Create an entire religion to explain my pregnancy." The bottom panel shows a painting of Mary, mother of Jesus wiping sweat from their forehead, clearly struggling with the decision.
https://files.mastodon.social/media_attachments/files/113/276/828/472/465/097/original/3a4bfffd3f284a78.png